How can I give romantic relationships a different place in my life?
July 10, 2012 6:28 AM Subscribe
How can I give romantic relationships a different place in my life?
I have a friend who never gets jealous or insecure about anything in her monogamous (in that they do not have sex with other people) long-term relationship. She's said that if her partner ever wanted to sleep with other people, she would be okay with it. She's okay with him doing pretty much everything and anything regarding other women, sex, and attention, and he has done so (except for sex.) They are very very independent, regularly travel without one another, and spend a lot of time apart, but they do love each other and are considerate of one another when they do spend time together.
I have been in short term casual relationships with people where I was very indifferent to most of the things that bother me now. The only thing that would have bothered me or would have been considered a betrayal is lying. Romantic entanglements with other people would have been fine as long as I was not being cheated on, in the sense of it being hidden, and as long as I was still being treated with respect.
I have been in my current relationship for almost four years and I definitely would be unhappy if he slept with other people. There are other things too, that we do not do and that most couples do/are okay with (such as porn), because we are not interested in doing those things and also, I think, because of insecurity. It seems to be working, but I can't shake that I "should" be more okay and laid back. The friend that I spoke of earlier told me that there is no "should" and she's right, but I'm thinking that if I were truly secure and confident, then I would not need such commitment. My relationship has for all these years been a big part of my life, whereas in the past, my relationships were not a big part of my life. I didn't need their sole attention, because their company was simply a nice addition to my day. Now my relationship is headed towards marriage and children. Anthropologically, children require resources such as time and money, therefore my partner would be more heavily involved in my life and the child's life on a day to day basis. But this still doesn't mean that my partner doesn't have time for sex with other people especially when the child is older.
I just feel if I were more enlightened, rational, confident, etc. I would not need much really from my partner aside from respect and care during the time we do spend together. And the rest of the time, how does it really affect me what he is doing so long as he doesn't contract an STD or get someone else pregnant (which would take away resources)?
So even though there is no "should," there kind of is. I do think part of this is that I don't want to get hurt. Sometimes I think I might be relieved if my partner cheated on me so I could just forget about relationships in the way I have learned to view them since being in my current long term relationship and just go back to how I used to be before.
How I think I was before is because I kept my emotional distance, but maybe I could even learn to be very emotionally close and loving, so much so that I'd never ever want to limit my partner in any way, even if that meant losing him, whether on the weekend while he spends it with another woman, or permanently. I'd just be happy that he was happy (so long as I was not being physically or emotionally abused). I guess I'm feeling as if monogamy is a sign of weakness in myself, a sign of my insecurity. And I don't want to be insecure and I don't want to get hurt.
So I suppose the questions are: are there any books or websites on this topic? Do you have any experience navigating this issue within your own relationships?
posted by anonymous to human relations (24 answers total) 16 users marked this as a favorite
there's this weird idea out there from a lot of open marriage and polyamory advocates that their choices are the "enlightened" ones. And I don't really blame them for this belief of theirs-- after all, everyone believes, on some level, that their way is "the right way" rather than merely just a personal choice.
Your friend has the sort of relationship with her SO that works for her and her SO. And you don't know what's going on inside that relationship, so there's no point in wishing that you were like her.
Is your relationship with your SO working for you? It sounds like it is. The question is if that's what you want, and why you want that. Or maybe you always envisioned yourself with a different kind of relationship than you have now. Or maybe you're so stuck in the pattern of your previous relationships that your current one, even though it seems good, is "unnatural" for you.
My advice is to stop believing that you should believe things that you think people in your "enlightened" cultural milieu believe and instead do what works for you. I guess my question would be why you think you have to conform to a value system in which you would have a more detached/open relationship. Because that's what you're doing here-- seeing other forms of relationships and cultural beliefs and believing that you need to conform to them.
posted by deanc at 6:46 AM on July 10, 2012 [4 favorites]