I'm looking for well-written sci-fi / fantasy, set in other worlds or the future, that isn't didactic or idea-driven.
December 16, 2003 10:57 AM
Subscribe
Like many other geeks here, I grew up reading sci-fi and fantasy. But I gradually got tired of it, because so much of it was poorly written or antithetical to my tastes. But I still yearn for other worlds at times, so I'd be interested in recommendations. [more inside.]
About my tastes: I HATE literature of ideas. This rules out a ton of SF, I know. I love ideas, but I prefer to get them from non-fiction. The only reason I read any fiction, is for plot and character. I like a really good story – a page-turner – and characters that I can fall in love with (or hate). I find that if there are too many ideas, then I start thinking about the author and that distances my emotional connection with the world. I stop believing in it.
But when you remove all the “smart” SF-novels, you tend to be left with “Xornon the Slobberer for Zabian IV,” poorly written hack stuff. Basically, I want well-written fiction, set in other worlds (or the future of this world) that isn’t didactic or idea-driven. In terms of writing style, I prefer the simple (think Hemingway and Carver), but I’m happy with anything that is evocative and not cliché-ridden.
Below, I’ll list some novels that I’ve enjoyed. Some of these might violate my “rules” – you might be able to think of them as idea novels – but the plot/character stuff in them is strong enough that I’ve was able to ignore any intellectual content while I was reading them and just get involved in the story.
Metropolitan & City on Fire by Walter Jon Williams
(the first book of the series) His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman
The Mars Books by Kim Stanley Robinson
The Iron Dragon’s Daughter by Michael Swanwick
A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter Millar Jr.
The Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin
I’ve also read most of the classics (Wells, Tolkien, CS Lewis, etc.)
[As a side note, I’d like to add that I’ve always enjoyed the Escape-from-dystopia genre (i.e. Logan’s Run), but It’s hard to find them. Does anyone know of any besides Logans Run, 1984, Brave New World, This Perfect Day (my favorite), and the Tripods Books.]
posted by grumblebee to media & arts (64 comments total)
5 users marked this as a favorite
posted by inksyndicate at 11:02 AM on December 16, 2003