CAD/Drafting on Linux - What software for strange bicycles?
April 25, 2016 5:00 PM Subscribe
What software should I use to create a parametric model of a bicycle and have the software generate plan views I can send to a welder/framebuilder.
Things I've tried:
- GeoGebra - It's great for ensuring that a folding bike's parts will end up in the right spot. Not great at drawing solid geometries like frame tubes, or generating plan views.
- OpenSCAD - I love it for 3D printing, but the dimensioning modules available are way too clunky for complex designs.
- Blender - nice for animation, but true parametric modelling is tricky, and it isn't designed to output dimensioned plans.
- FreeCAD - it'll probably be a great piece of software within the next decade, but doesn't seem to be there yet.
- BikeCAD and RattleCAD - nice software for designing a regular diamond frame. But the world has enough of those, so I design folding/recumbent bikes.
Features I would like:
- Parametric modelling (I can define variables for wheelbase, seat height, etc. and let the software calculate dependent points, which change dynamically as I edit the basic parameters)
- Outputs plan drawings I can drop off with a framebuilder
- Runs on Linux
- A supportive community that generates lots of tutorials would be awesome
I'm willing to pay for it, but not really excited about the prospect. If it's paid, a demo version would be handy.
Things I've tried:
- GeoGebra - It's great for ensuring that a folding bike's parts will end up in the right spot. Not great at drawing solid geometries like frame tubes, or generating plan views.
- OpenSCAD - I love it for 3D printing, but the dimensioning modules available are way too clunky for complex designs.
- Blender - nice for animation, but true parametric modelling is tricky, and it isn't designed to output dimensioned plans.
- FreeCAD - it'll probably be a great piece of software within the next decade, but doesn't seem to be there yet.
- BikeCAD and RattleCAD - nice software for designing a regular diamond frame. But the world has enough of those, so I design folding/recumbent bikes.
Features I would like:
- Parametric modelling (I can define variables for wheelbase, seat height, etc. and let the software calculate dependent points, which change dynamically as I edit the basic parameters)
- Outputs plan drawings I can drop off with a framebuilder
- Runs on Linux
- A supportive community that generates lots of tutorials would be awesome
I'm willing to pay for it, but not really excited about the prospect. If it's paid, a demo version would be handy.
Have you seen Onshape? I'm still learning how to fully drive it, but coming from a Pro/E background it's by far the most powerful free CAD software I've tried.
posted by trialex at 2:53 AM on April 26, 2016
posted by trialex at 2:53 AM on April 26, 2016
Response by poster: Onshape looks neat - and I'm normally wary of webapps! But I don't think my graphics card supports WebGL, which Onshape requires. So no dice there, unless I upgrade from this ancient netbook to a modern computer. (-:
posted by sibilatorix at 3:35 PM on April 26, 2016
posted by sibilatorix at 3:35 PM on April 26, 2016
Response by poster: Well, I never did get OnShape working.
I think I'm going to use FreeCAD after all. It does have the tools I need for parametric bicycle design, they're just clunky and unintuitive. Folks on the FreeCAD forum answered some questions and offered a few tips.
posted by sibilatorix at 11:01 PM on May 4, 2016
I think I'm going to use FreeCAD after all. It does have the tools I need for parametric bicycle design, they're just clunky and unintuitive. Folks on the FreeCAD forum answered some questions and offered a few tips.
posted by sibilatorix at 11:01 PM on May 4, 2016
« Older Can I get a US green card if we are both in Canada... | Health care proxy has been invoked. What power... Newer »
This thread is closed to new comments.
It may place you back into FreeCAD, which could end up being the most relevant option though perhaps not perfect. I hope its accompanying packages will help.
http://caelinux.com/CMS/
posted by mr_bovis at 7:47 PM on April 25, 2016