Should I eat it? Hard boiled eggs left in water over night. [more inside]
posted by molecicco on Oct 24, 2009 - 27 answers

ShouldIEatIt Filter: We both ate the same thing. He threw up, I'm fine. Is it OK to eat the leftovers? [more inside]
posted by castlebravo on Sep 17, 2009 - 25 answers

Should I eat it and how, the cooked shrimp edition. [more inside]
posted by desjardins on Jan 26, 2009 - 14 answers

Should I eat it filter: Can of Bumblebee whole baby clams. Dumped them into my chowder only to notice that they looked a bit green. Google indicates this might be algae in their tummies? Should I eat them? Chowder is currently simmering, but will be tossed if that is what I need to do.
posted by silkygreenbelly on Jan 12, 2009 - 15 answers

Edible filter: I've discovered that my experience of peaches burning, and peach fuzz being like a cactus, is an allergy that came along with puberty. Essentially what should be sweet and tart tastes sweet, tart and spicey. I don't mind the afterburn, but what happens if you keep eating allergy triggering food? [more inside]
posted by Phalene on Nov 26, 2008 - 8 answers

Caramel wafers one year after 'best by'. Should I eat them? [more inside]
posted by of strange foe on Sep 16, 2008 - 23 answers

There is a small pile of garden zucchini that has been sitting on the kitchen counter for about two months, right between the sink and an always-open window (to let in the Cleveland summer). Should I eat it?
posted by waxboy on Sep 2, 2008 - 21 answers