26 posts tagged with shouldieatit.
Displaying 1 through 26 of 26. Subscribe:

Can I eat it: fridge left ajar

My fridge was possibly* left ajar for... who knows. A day? I immediately measured some food with my accurate-to-+/-2F thermometer and it all came out at 37-38F. I come from a VERY food-paranoid family so I have no concept of what is 'normal food safety'. The only things that really 'need' to be refrigerated are a dozen eggs (bought yesterday, sigh), yogurt, cheese, and some leftover stir-fry (vegetarian) + cooked brown rice... Am I good to go? [more inside]
posted by flibbertigibbet on Dec 30, 2016 - 20 answers

I'll probably try it anyway, but...

Should I eat it? I found a bag of mini babybel cheeses in my fridge. (Like this.) They have a best-before date of.... well... uh... January. (Hey, at least it's still 2016!). They're wrapped in plastic, and then in their distinctive wax. I unwrapped one - it looks totally fine. I want to eat this. I mean... it's cheese. If it's not mouldy its good, right? But... January. Would you eat it?
posted by cgg on Sep 20, 2016 - 13 answers

Can we eat it: colorful udon edition

We recently bought udon with a "use by" date of "May 12 16," except one has some weird orange spots (looks like colorful flavoring accidentally included from something else, and the second instance of weird purple-like tint and possibly a bit of slimy consistency. Here's a photo, with the areas in question circled for emphasis. Can we eat it, eat around it, or should we chuck it? [more inside]
posted by filthy light thief on Dec 27, 2015 - 13 answers

Should I Eat It: Holiday Edition

So I screwed up. We're having early Thanksgiving this weekend. My wife picked up a local turkey, frozen, stored it in a refrigerator, and gave it to me to take home and do either a sink thaw or put it in our fridge. "Don't leave it in the car," she said. Guess what? [more inside]
posted by middleclasstool on Nov 20, 2015 - 31 answers

Safe to eat sous vide pork shoulder after power outage?

Cooking a pork shoulder sous vide, but had a power outage last night that killed the heater/circulator... [more inside]
posted by griffey on Mar 30, 2015 - 10 answers

Is improperly-stored salsa safe to eat?

Please reassure me that eating this questionable item is fine! I opened a jar of salsa and the left it (closed, unrefrigerated) in my backpack for a week. Oops! I've been pretty sleep-deprived of late, and so more forgetful than usual. [more inside]
posted by i. shishkin on Dec 17, 2014 - 29 answers

Can I drink it: Prohibition edition

I've been helping my mom and grandmother clean out my late great-aunt's apartment. She was a hoarder. One of the things I found today was a small bottle of Prohibition-era whiskey. [more inside]
posted by nonasuch on Nov 13, 2014 - 21 answers

Should I eat it: meal delivery edition

Food delivery company says their pre-made meals are good in the fridge for a week. This seems way too long--much longer than I would ever store homemade food. Should I trust my gut or do the professionals know something about food safety that I don't? [more inside]
posted by insoluble uncertainty on Oct 13, 2014 - 16 answers

should I eat it: self-propelling anchovy paste

I just opened a brand-new tube of anchovy paste to make salad dressing, and when I punctured the seal on the tube, it started to spout anchovy paste, as if the whole thing had been under pressure. It smells and looks fine, but emerged with surprising and alarming velocity. [more inside]
posted by dizziest on Mar 19, 2014 - 11 answers

One pork roast with froth, please.

Should I eat fizzy pork? [more inside]
posted by OrangeDrink on Nov 27, 2013 - 21 answers

Space Jam II

My jam did the thing again -- it levitated in the jar overnight. I took a photo this time. I'm asking again in the hopes that someone new may have a definitive answer, as I'd like to know for sure if this means the jam is now inedible. [more inside]
posted by (alice) on Nov 17, 2013 - 34 answers

gimme shellter

Is eating peanut shells on a regular basis a bad idea? [more inside]
posted by threeants on Jan 25, 2013 - 8 answers

Food-Grade Spikenard Oil

Is spikenard inherently unsafe for human consumption? If not, where can I get some food-grade spikenard oil? If so, what is the closest equivalent spice?
posted by jedicus on Jan 18, 2013 - 5 answers

Spoiled for Choice, Sour by Choice?

Sour Milk, Soured Milk, and Spoiled Milk. Is there an effective chemical difference? To what extents are any and all unsafe to cook and eat? [more inside]
posted by Ambrosia Voyeur on May 30, 2012 - 9 answers

Why does my wheat smell like beets?

Did my flour go bad? I have some wheat flour from a small local farm. I used it to make bread today and it has an odd smell. I'm wondering if it's still okay to use or if I'll be tripping like a medieval peasant if I eat it. [more inside]
posted by apricot on Mar 3, 2012 - 6 answers

Should We Eat It: Wedding Cake

Should we eat it... a year from now? [The Wedding Cake Edition] [more inside]
posted by charmcityblues on Sep 20, 2011 - 27 answers

Lime Overtime

Should I Eat It: Battle Lime Juice! I left the lime juice out overnight and just noticed it. It's pretty hot today, around 85ºF inside. The bottle says "refrigerate after opening". Verdict?
posted by ignignokt on Jul 21, 2011 - 15 answers

Egg drop soup left out of the fridge for 12 hours. Should I eat it?

My wife left a container of egg drop soup on the kitchen counter overnight. It's been sitting there for 12 hours now. I am very hungry. I love egg drop soup. Should I eat it?
posted by gertzedek on Jun 30, 2011 - 36 answers

Can this Minestrone be Saved?

Can I Eat It: Part 7,934 in an ongoing series. In a fit of industriousness, I made Cannellini Minestrone this morning! I put part of it in a container for my lunch, and part of it in a container to store in the fridge. I realized once I got to work, however, that the container to store never made it to the fridge, and is still sitting on the counter in my apartment. The soup was made at 8am, and I won't be getting home until 8pm. Can anything be done to salvage the soup into something edible, or at least usable?
posted by ocherdraco on Feb 16, 2011 - 27 answers


Should I eat it? Hard boiled eggs left in water over night. [more inside]
posted by molecicco on Oct 24, 2009 - 27 answers

Have the food poisoning gods smiled on me?

ShouldIEatIt Filter: We both ate the same thing. He threw up, I'm fine. Is it OK to eat the leftovers? [more inside]
posted by castlebravo on Sep 17, 2009 - 25 answers

Should I eat it and if so, how?

Should I eat it and how, the cooked shrimp edition. [more inside]
posted by desjardins on Jan 26, 2009 - 14 answers

Dump my delicious chowder down the sink or down my throat?

Should I eat it filter: Can of Bumblebee whole baby clams. Dumped them into my chowder only to notice that they looked a bit green. Google indicates this might be algae in their tummies? Should I eat them? Chowder is currently simmering, but will be tossed if that is what I need to do.
posted by silkygreenbelly on Jan 12, 2009 - 15 answers

Om Nom Burning!

Edible filter: I've discovered that my experience of peaches burning, and peach fuzz being like a cactus, is an allergy that came along with puberty. Essentially what should be sweet and tart tastes sweet, tart and spicey. I don't mind the afterburn, but what happens if you keep eating allergy triggering food? [more inside]
posted by Phalene on Nov 26, 2008 - 8 answers

Should I eat the caramel wafers?

Caramel wafers one year after 'best by'. Should I eat them? [more inside]
posted by of strange foe on Sep 16, 2008 - 23 answers

Safe to eat?

There is a small pile of garden zucchini that has been sitting on the kitchen counter for about two months, right between the sink and an always-open window (to let in the Cleveland summer). Should I eat it?
posted by waxboy on Sep 2, 2008 - 21 answers

Page: 1