Ask MetaFilter questions tagged with loans and finances

Can bank charge off auto loan with totaled car despite continued payments?

Nickel — Sun, 11 Oct 2009 22:55:56 -0800

Car was totaled, bank that gave auto loan charged off the loan account because the collateral is gone despite us continuing with full and on time payments. What are our options? Our car was considered totaled by the insurance company, but the insurance company is refusing to pay for various reasons (not the point of this post, we've already hired a lawyer) so we can't pay off the loan in full. We've continued to make monthly payments in full to the bank that holds the loan.

However, the bank then sends us a letter saying they are charging off the account. A check of the credit report confirms that they have listed it as a negative account there. We call/write with proof that all payments have been made on time and in the full amount, they respond that it is their policy to charge off loans that have lost their collateral.

Is this legit? What are our options? It just seems wrong that they can charge off an account when we've been making all the payments and have proof of our payments.

What lender should I pick for my student loans?

amalgamator — Thu, 16 Apr 2009 21:36:15 -0800

Which lender should I use for my government student loans? I have previously attended a direct loan school and thus I had to take out my Stafford and GradPLUS loans through the school directly. I am now going to another school that is FFELP school and I can choose my lender. I was given a preferred list from the school. I remember reading that sometimes the preferred list isn't the best deal around. And that you should shop around. However, I've read that it's getting harder and harder to find great borrower benefits such as waiving loan origination fees.

I found a list of the top 100 lenders. Yet #1 on that list is Sallie Mae which is a terrible company?

Have any of you found a lender that you like with good benefits? Anything else I'm missing?

Loan Woes

Anonymous — Thu, 15 May 2008 04:12:32 -0800

My partner and I need to acquire a loan for her grad school. The catch(es): She's not a citizen. We're gay. We don't have the first clue how to go about doing this. Help! My partner is from Canada. A Canadian loan is out of the question. (Period! Don't even suggest Canadian student aid...it won't help!)

She has one year of grad school left, which will be around $30,000. I make a pretty good living here in the midwest (less than triple digits, but not substantially less), though the two of us must live on my single income, but paying off the loan shouldn't be too difficult. We're young. My credit is right there in the middle, not great, not wonderful.

I've never done this before. Please explain how to prepare, what I can expect, who I should ask (my bank? other lenders?), what criteria makes a lender more likely to approve a loan, should we ask for a personal or financial loan, and if we have a chance in hell of pulling this off, given the current economic climate. I am a babe in the woods, please be kind, and my one caveat must be: please do not pass judgment on our situation, financially, emotionally, or otherwise.

Thanks in advance for your help. It is much needed and much appreciated.

Seeking guidance with financial planning (loans, down payment, more)

mintchip — Sun, 20 Apr 2008 16:55:09 -0800

Seeking guidance with financial planning (loans, down payment, more) I've searched through the questions already asked but didn't see anything quite like this. My situation:

1. I am graduating with a very large student loan debt (more than 50k, less than 100k).
2. I have excellent credit.
3. I have no other debt or loans.
4. I have some retirement savings.
5. I don't expect to have a huge salary.
6. I am considering going back for another degree in a year or two--probably one that would result in a significantly higher salary

I'm going to move home for a year or two. I am considering using my cost savings to pay off a large portion of my loans. This appeals to me, except for a few reasons:

1. If I do go back to school (and this is by no means a definite), will having a large debt be to my advantage as far as getting need-based grants and other aid from my school?
2. It seems like housing prices are going to keep going down. Many of the people I know who are financially well off got that way by buying their home when real estate values were low. I could potentially save a large down payment (>20%) in a short amount of time. Also, although my loans are burdensome, the rates aren't horrible (they are all federal loans) and with inflation they will get a little less painful over time (in other words, a fixed monthly payment of $xx will feel like a lot less a few years into the future when money has less value).
3. Although unlikely, is it possible that the government would offer debt relief opportunities for people saddled down by student loans--let's say if the economy gets even worse?

I could also pay off a big chunk of the loans (but not all) and then start saving for a down payment.

(Is it worth it to see a financial planner?)

car lease, income, and credit score

dannon205 — Sun, 16 Mar 2008 22:42:33 -0800

How much is a high income factoredd into a car lease loan decision? I want to lease a new Honda Accord. My credit isn't that great due to some missed payments back in law school and about $80K in student loan debt. Other than that I only have $4K in a car debt, but no credit card debt. My score is about 630. I make $100K/yr w/ a discretionary bonus. I'd be willing to put the 20% down (which the down payment is capped at), plus the 1st months payment and security deposit.

Does anyone know well enough how car lease companies decide whether to loan money for a lease? I understand that generally you need a pretty high credit score, but how much do they factor in income?

Finding a way out of a tangled web of financial aid

dead_ — Tue, 05 Jun 2007 10:05:20 -0800

I've reached the end of the road for graduate school loans. Well, I was finally accepted to a master's program at my first choice school: Waseda University in Tokyo, Japan. Little did I know that funding my adventure in higher education would prove so ridiculously troublesome and depressing.

My situation is easily summed up as follows: no one wants to give me a loan.

In detail, it goes something like this: I cannot receive any kind of federal loan for graduate school, as my university doesn't admit many American students and as such has no relationship with the Department of Education here in the states--this means that Stafford loans are out of the question. Also, it is an impossibility for the university to get a FAFSA number through the DOE (thus allowing for federal funds) due to the length and intensity of the process and the relatively few American students at the school. I've talked with both the university, and the DOE on that one.

I also seem to have hit a roadblock with private loans. I have found many loans that allow deferred payment and disbursement of funds directly to me, yet during the application process I always encounter the mysterious "eligibility list" of universities they approve or do not approve of--which of course Waseda is not on, excluding me from the loan. After speaking with a few financial aid officers, I realized that these lists are of universities that banks have relationships with so they can determine if the student is still enrolled at full-time (and thus still eligible for the loan). So it looks like private loans are out, too. I've checked hundreds of them, with no luck.

The university itself offers no loans to foreign students, and has no relationships with any US financial institutions.

As for scholarships, I will undoubtedly get them--and have been told as much--however they are not awarded until after matriculation and the initial tuition payments, which I would need a loan to make. I also have no way of knowing how much I'm getting yet.

So what is a foreign-enrolled US citizen to do, with no one to loan him a dollar and his dream school slipping away? That's what I'm asking you.

This has been one of the most disheartening experiences of my life: a long, detailed admissions process fraught with doubt that eventually resulted in the wonderful news of admission to my dream school, and yet now I have no way to finance it--even with the almost certain possibility of scholarship.

Are there any options I haven't tried, or haven't thought of here? Is there anything I can do?

Repairing Credit

Anonymous — Wed, 10 Nov 2004 19:45:33 -0800

How should I repair my bad credit? I'm 26, my income ($53k) exceeds my expenses and I have only $1.5k debt, but I was awful about paying bills on time until the last year or so. Now I'm finding it difficult to secure a car loan. I haven't even gotten a credit report because I'm afraid to look at it. I will probably end up talking to a credit counselor, but I thought I'd ask for advice before I do. College kids, don't wait until the utility bill is yellow to pay it. Trust me.

Mortgage advice/opinion relevant to the UK?

squealy — Fri, 23 Apr 2004 06:17:30 -0800

Mortgage advice/opinion relevant to the UK? (More inside) I'm in the UK and the fixed rate period of my mortgage is due to run out in June. Now, I know little of economics and even less of financial planning, but it's fairly clear even from my limited knowledge that the 5.99% variable rate I'm due to move on to is not the best deal available. The mortgage is only for £40,000 and the house is now worth about £70,000, so there's no problem with equity. I don't intend to move house within the next five years. Anyone have any knowledge/opinions on what's the "best" type of mortgage or even a specific policy? I've seen a couple of financial advisers but they both had wildly differing advice. I'd be interested in a MeFi take on the issue as I'm a bit of a numpty when it comes to financial matters.