Comments on: PC iPod + New Macbook = Headache

Question: PC iPod + New Macbook = Headache

Hollow — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 14:30:06 -0800

PCtoMacFilter: Is there an easier (faster) way to get my 37 gigs of music stranded on my PC formatted iPod onto my new Macbook than copying it to a PC with 3rd party software, burning it to dvds, and then ripping the dvds onto the Mac? Apple says "no," but please tell me they are wrong.

By: socratic

socratic — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 14:31:30 -0800

Does Senuti work with a PC-formatted ipod? I think it worked with mine but that was ages ago. http://www.fadingred.org/senuti/

By: Blazecock Pileon

Blazecock Pileon — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 14:35:36 -0800

If your Windows PC and MacBook PC are on the same network, you could transfer the files via Windows File Sharing.

By: Good Brain

Good Brain — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 14:37:00 -0800

Yes, you are making it way more difficult than it needs to be.

By: forthright

forthright — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 14:37:34 -0800

Well, I can't authoritatively answer your question, but I own several PCs (Mac Mini, HP running Ubuntu, HP running Vista) and I just keep all my music and audio books as MP3s in a shared folder on the Ubuntu box, and then listen to them using either Winamp, iTunes or Amarok, depending on the box...they all see the same shared files.

I connect my 5th gen iPod to the Mac Mini and drag and drop playlists onto it.

I have found the above approach to be very easy and flexible, but granted I have always used the iPod with the Mac so you would first need to get past that obstacle. But I don't see why burning DVDs would be necessary (???).

By: heresiarch

heresiarch — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 15:29:45 -0800

They're definitely wrong. PC-formatted stuff can be read from a mac (but not written, unless you've done something fancy to it), so you should be able to plug your PC ipod into your mac and follow Good Brain's advice. If the command line stuff is too technical, something like this app or the Senuti app mentioned above should work fine.

By: damn dirty ape

damn dirty ape — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 15:50:54 -0800

I dont think he has a PC. Just a pc-formated ipod (why apple continues to keep two different formats on the same player is beyond me).

By: quarterframer

quarterframer — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 16:40:47 -0800

Floola is free and will work. Download the Mac version and drag it onto your iPod in the Finder. Make sure iTunes is NOT running. Start it with a double click (you actually run it off the iPod). You can then use it to transfer music or movies to/from the iPod.

I use Floola on my PC formatted iPod on OSX, XP, and Ubuntu with no problem.

And there are a zillion other ways to do it too, per Google.

By: LunaticFringe

LunaticFringe — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 16:50:15 -0800

My boyfriend just bought a macbook pro and owns a windows formatted iPod. We found that he could use his use iTunes normally with his new computer and old iPod without having to reformat it. He can transfer "new" music and see all of his "old" music. We haven't tried to rip the old music off though so if that's your goal then sorry, this comment will be rendered useless. Good luck and enjoy the mac!

By: SemiSophos

SemiSophos — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 17:56:22 -0800

Your FAT32 (Windows) formatted iPod will work fine on the Mac. There are three main (Free and Open) tools for ripping music back to the computer from the iPod: Senuti, Yamipod, and Floola.

Socratic nailed it in the first response, but Senuti rocks. I have used it quite a few times.

Yamipod and Floola share quite a bit of code. The main difference is the interface. Yamipod has been around quite a bit longer.

By: Kosh

Kosh — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 18:05:45 -0800

Adding to the chorus, Senuti did this perfectly for me when I made the switch a couple years ago. It grabbed all the music off of my FAT32 iPod and placed it on the Mac with no problems. I then used iTunes to reformat the iPod for Mac and resynced everything. No need to mess with trying to get the Mac and the PC to talk to each other over a network.

And my pure conjecture would be that Apple still maintains two different formats for the classic iPods because of disk mode issues; that is, people using them as portable USB drives. I don't think Windows Explorer can write to HFS+ (the default Mac filesystem) volumes without special software, and I presume Apple prefers HFS+ for Mac-formatted iPods because (a) it's a better filesystem than FAT and (b) Apple probably wants to use their own FS for their products wherever possible.

By: Mikey-San

Mikey-San — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 19:23:30 -0800

You might want to burn those DVDs anyway. "Stranded"+ "copy to my PC, then move to Mac" sounds like "I have only one copy of my music and it's on my iPod". Having a backup wouldn't hurt.

By: Hollow

Hollow — Sat, 15 Mar 2008 20:27:18 -0800

Thanks everyone. Senuti worked great. I just downloaded it on my Macbook, plugged in my iPod, pulled off my music directly into my iTunes library, reformatted my iPod, and put it back on. Incidentally, I had earlier called Apple support and asked if I could do exactly this. They said no. Metafilter: 1. Apple: 0.

By: Remy

Remy — Sun, 16 Mar 2008 06:50:16 -0800

Incidentally, I had earlier called Apple support and asked if I could do exactly this. They said no.

Apple's not going to recommend third party tools to circumvent their very minor copy prevention they've built into the system. If they wanted you to routinely be able to do something like this, they would've built it into iTunes.

(And to that end, they have, sort of: when you plug an iPod into a machine it's not set to sync with, it now allows you to transfer your iTMS purchased music off the iPod to the machine in question, so long as you burn an activation on that machine.)

By: thomas144

thomas144 — Sun, 16 Mar 2008 06:52:58 -0800

Senuti is the greatest computer program ever written!