Daughter of a Chinese fiance/wife is facing deportation, because the gov't dragged their feet. Is there recourse?
July 12, 2007 2:22 PM   RSS feed for this thread Subscribe

I have a friend who has a dire immigration problem. He, a US citizen, married and relocated his wife and her daughter from China to the US. The INS is going to deport her daughter. We want to fight it. Lengthy details, of varying complexity involving government malfeasance, etc. inside.

I'd really like some insight and pointers to resources we can use to influence some decisionmakers at the INS and elsewhere. The situation is (with some details probably wrong):
My friend and his wife began an extended long-term relationship via the Internet, and he eventually went to China to meet her. While there, he proposed and she accepted, which included relocating her, and her daughter to the US. In 2004, they applied, and about a year later, received K-1 and K-2 visas (his wife received a K-1 - aka "fiance visa",her daughter, a K-2" - which applies specifically to the offspring of a K-1 nonimmigrant). His wife came here in early 2005 and her daughter arrived in July of 2005 (as she graduated from high school). The daughter is classified as a "K-2 non-immigrant" under the LIFE provisions in immigration law. The law is pretty clear: K-2 non-immigrants must be under 21 years old. The daughter turned 21 in April of this year. If she had waited until she was 20 to apply, that would be one thing, but she didn't wait very long.

In 2005 the family applied for "adjustment of status" for the daughter.
There have been a series of quite extended delays on the part of the INS - one delay of 180 days and another of over 100 days - a rejected application and subsequent resubmittal, and a lost letter as a result of a change of address, her application for residency (form I-485) was rejected because the she is 21 now, even though she wasn't 21 at the time the application was made - she was 18. She has sixty days to depart. There is a process whereby a motion to reopen can be sent to the INS, but there is no appeal possible, she has to refile her application. They have no money to support this - refiling costs about $900.00.
Because of the visa requirements, neither the mother or daughter are allowed to work, and my friend, the husband, was disabled last year. So they have no financial resources other than some small pensions.

It's pretty obvious, when you look at the timeline, that if this process were handled in a timely manner by the INS, she would have been approved. The i's were all dotted, the T's were all crossed, the requirements were more than met by the family. The only reason they denied the change in status is because she turned 21 while on a K-2 visa. The process from applying for the adjustment to status was filed very shortly after the daughter arrived, and it took over a year to process.
The only reason she was denied, in short, is because the INS dragged their feet throughout the process.

Questions:
When I review the K-2 visa information available on the Internet, it appears that the "I-485 Adjustment of status" is the only real method for someone in her position (a minor's mother married an American who brought the immigrant back with them) to get a different type of visa or status (such as an immigrant visa rather than a non-immigrant visa). Is this really the case or are there loopholes somewhere?

We will be filing a motion to reopen her application, which is the only step we can take. Is there anything we should do to prepare for, and respond with, to make this process go smoothly?

Are there any free/low cost organizations that can help us? it's obviously a complicated problem and will take some horsepower to solve.
Thanks in advance for your help.
posted by disclaimer to law & government (13 comments total) 2 users marked this as a favorite
My wife is an immigration attorney and at least one day a month they let folks come in for free consultations. I'd call around different immigration law firms and see if they do the same. Also, you can ask them for local groups that help out folks in situations like this.

Are there any local Chinese groups that can help?

I'm an engineer and pride myself on being reasonable intelligent, but immigration law is almost incomprehensible to me. Best of luck to your friends.
posted by beowulf573 at 2:39 PM on July 12, 2007


Try the Asian Pacific American Legal Center.

They will absolutely want an immigration lawyer for this.
posted by rtha at 2:42 PM on July 12, 2007


Also, they should contact their representatives in Congress and the Senate.
posted by Carol Anne at 2:52 PM on July 12, 2007


The poster lives in northern Oakland County, Michigan, where this lawyer or this lawyer can help.
posted by megatherium at 2:57 PM on July 12, 2007


Ugh. That's close to standard practice at the Kafka-endorsed USCIS. It's certainly not an isolated case.

Call the relevant Congresscritters' offices. This is the kind of situation where your friend really needs to start going through unusual channels. (And Senator Levin has some history of pulling legislative strings for Michigan residents.)

Also, call the local press. The current climate has created a backwash against all immigrants, even those who follow the rules to the letter, but that's mitigated by having a US citizen involved in this fuckup. It may also help get your friend and his family some pro bono support.
posted by holgate at 3:14 PM on July 12, 2007


You might want to direct them to the VisaJourney forums. There are other people there who have dealt with "age-out" issues.
posted by thirteenkiller at 3:16 PM on July 12, 2007


Your friend's Congressperson/Senator should be willing to help. Your friend needs to be the one to call as he's the one who can vote.

Honestly, having been through the system myself, I'd say get a lawyer. I know you said they don't have any money, but really, get a loan or find somebody willing to do pro bono work or something. This is not the time to be DIY. The USCIS is extremely difficult to navigate without an experienced immigration attorney. Mine was worth of every penny.
posted by joannemerriam at 3:29 PM on July 12, 2007


The AILF has an awesome clearing house of immigration litigation information. See if a mandamus application is appropriate in your situation.

Unfortunately for you it is a bad time to try and hire an immigration lawyer and/or get an I-485 application adjudicated due to the ongoing visa bulletin fiasco and the pending class action litigation in that matter.
posted by crazycanuck at 3:43 PM on July 12, 2007


On second reading, it looks like mandamus is not for you. Poke through some of the other cases on that site until you find one that looks like yours so you know the right key words to use when you get a lawyer. Good luck.
posted by crazycanuck at 3:52 PM on July 12, 2007


Nthing getting an immigration lawyer, having gone from an H1-B to a green card myself, I am very glad I had a lawyer to help. Holgate's description of the INS as being kafka-endorsed is absolutely perfect. Having a lawyer saved my bacon, good ones know people at the INS and can call and sort out minor snafus. Also, they understand the spaghetti that is immigration law. Hopefully some of the other posts in this thread will help you find pro bono resources, but if not, just beg, borrow or steal the money to hire a lawyer.
posted by Joh at 4:59 PM on July 12, 2007


In most cases, the influence of a congressman or senator can make the difference. Write to them and have your friend write to them and have as many friends as you can locate write to them.
posted by JJ86 at 6:07 PM on July 12, 2007


You guys are the best. We're going to take a look at a lot of your suggestions but we've got some things to work with now. If anyone has anything else they can offer, I'd appreciate it, and I'll best-answer some of these tomorrow.

Thanks!
posted by disclaimer at 7:27 PM on July 12, 2007


My Chinese friend recommends 2 forum links for information about exactly such topics - (Both in Chinese)
posted by growabrain at 10:53 PM on July 12, 2007


« Older What is the stimulant in Airbo...   |   New employer has done a backgr... Newer »
This thread is closed to new comments.