Comments on: Deaf-Blind and Mute Children: How Taught? How Much Communication? Life From Their Eyes?

Question: Deaf-Blind and Mute Children: How Taught? How Much Communication? Life From Their Eyes?

bonaldi — Thu, 26 Feb 2004 07:38:31 -0800

Deaf-blind question. I ask only out of curiosity, but google turns up academic stuff that's above my head. How are deaf-blind children taught? What level of communication can they attain? Does being mute make a difference? Do we know what life is like inside a mind that has only touch/taste/smell senses of the world?

I'm thinking mainly of those who are born deaf and blind.

By: Goofyy

Goofyy — Thu, 26 Feb 2004 08:06:32 -0800

Google Helen Keller

By: bonaldi

bonaldi — Thu, 26 Feb 2004 08:46:27 -0800

That's very interesting stuff indeed. Although she was born with sight and hearing, so would have picked up some amount of language and frames of reference already, wouldn't she?

By: orange swan

orange swan — Thu, 26 Feb 2004 09:56:17 -0800

I recommend this recent thread about Helen Keller, which links to a terrific New Yorker article that debunks many of the myths about her. The thread also includes the ubiquitous saucy comments courtesy of quonsar.

By: jessamyn

jessamyn — Thu, 26 Feb 2004 12:01:46 -0800

In a general sense, one of the things that is interesting about any deaf children learning a language is that if they learn ASL [or whatever other local sign language they might learn] when they learn to talk, they are almost naturally going to learn English [or whatever language they read in] second. Many deaf kids -- and this is not getting to deaf-blind kids just yet -- learn to read in a completely different language than they learned to speak in, since ASL is not at all the same, syntactically, as spoken English. Depending on the level of hearing-loss, some kids who are just mostly deaf -- i.e. can hear with strong hearing aids -- have at least an inkling of spoken English. Fully deaf kids who learned sign learn a completely new language when they learn to read. Depending how this is taught, this can be a major impediment to further schooling.

Deaf kids who speak ASL also have problems with pronouns since spoken pronouns have specifi referents "he" "she" "you" whereas in ASL, they are gestures: pointing towards the other person for "you, pointing at oneself for "I". It's hard to teach pronouns to kids who learned ASL as a first language because the idea of "you" being relative is confusing [they think the pronoun they should use to refer to themselves is "you" because that's what everyong else says]. Many people who are deaf-blind use a different version of sign language called deaf-blind manual which allows the signs to be felt on the hand of the person you are speaking with.

As far as how this relates to deaf-blind kids, I know less. I've gone to DB-link in the past but it has some new java app that is cruel to my browser. Easier for looking at is the A-Z to Deafblindness [made by a guy who is deaf-blind himself] which I think will keep you occupied for quite a while.