Best Naturopathy school in Melbourne?
August 18, 2006 8:36 PM Subscribe
My wife wants to study Naturopathy in Melbourne, Australia and she needs some guidance as to which school she should sign up for: a) Australian College of Natural Medicine or b) The Southern School of Natural Therapy...... Both are the same cost.
Here I go again - try asking your question on the Lonely Planet Thorn Tree branch for Australasia.
The Thorn Tree is a terrific resource for all kinds of information on all kinds of places.
posted by Kirth Gerson at 4:58 AM on August 19, 2006
The Thorn Tree is a terrific resource for all kinds of information on all kinds of places.
posted by Kirth Gerson at 4:58 AM on August 19, 2006
I'm a massage therapist from Melbourne and have looked at studying Naturopathy at both the Southern School and the ACNM.
My personal preference is the Southern School - I dreamt of going there back in the late 80s when I first became interested in Naturopathy. It has a fantastic reputation and is very well known and respected in the industry.
I have done some of the course modules, but I ended up going to ACNM, purely for convenience as they offer part time, evening and external options.
posted by goshling at 5:36 AM on August 19, 2006
My personal preference is the Southern School - I dreamt of going there back in the late 80s when I first became interested in Naturopathy. It has a fantastic reputation and is very well known and respected in the industry.
I have done some of the course modules, but I ended up going to ACNM, purely for convenience as they offer part time, evening and external options.
posted by goshling at 5:36 AM on August 19, 2006
A friend in Melbourne studied acupuncture and massage at ACNM. She was pretty positive about the school, her program and (most of) her teachers. She did a lot of hands-on clinics as well as theory, and she participated in a student clinic regularly, and now has a successful practice of her own.
I have to fess up though… I thought her course was pretty shoddy. I can't stress enough that this is my personal opinion, based on a data point of exactly one, but they didn't seem terribly rigorous with assessment. And she regularly told me about classmates who were bleeding idiots in the clinics – abrasive and unsympathetic. She took her studies very seriously and was (is!), I think, a very good acupuncturist. But I did wonder about the others. Why wasn't the school picking up their abrasiveness / uselessness in student clinics? They could well have I suppose – that just wasn't part of the story.
My only experience with the Southern School was a couple of visits to their student clinic. It was great. The students really knew their stuff, were super-nice and fixed the problem I'd come in with.
posted by t0astie at 6:39 PM on August 20, 2006
I have to fess up though… I thought her course was pretty shoddy. I can't stress enough that this is my personal opinion, based on a data point of exactly one, but they didn't seem terribly rigorous with assessment. And she regularly told me about classmates who were bleeding idiots in the clinics – abrasive and unsympathetic. She took her studies very seriously and was (is!), I think, a very good acupuncturist. But I did wonder about the others. Why wasn't the school picking up their abrasiveness / uselessness in student clinics? They could well have I suppose – that just wasn't part of the story.
My only experience with the Southern School was a couple of visits to their student clinic. It was great. The students really knew their stuff, were super-nice and fixed the problem I'd come in with.
posted by t0astie at 6:39 PM on August 20, 2006
« Older Help me use my digital projecter with my MacBook... | Sunblock and bug repellent already secured. Newer »
This thread is closed to new comments.
Why?
Although the Australian College has accreditation with the National Training Information Service (I get errors for some reason searching for the other one), I suppose I would harbour credibility doubts about an organisation associated with the College of Natural Beauty. That's just a personal reaction thing.
Also, it appears that the Southern group run Bachelor programs which suggests to me that they would likely have a better reputation. As you saw from the Info. service, Australian College is accredited for Diplomas.
These are just my reactions - I'm not saying I've characterized these institutions carefully or properly: it's simply my gut response from having a cursory look.
What I would really recommend to my sister or wife would be to write to both institutions and ask them why each should be picked over the other. I would probably also recommend contacting one or more of the places linked on this page to see how each is regarded/listed/described (and particularly VTAC I think).
posted by peacay at 4:20 AM on August 19, 2006