skip to main content
Join 3,377 readers in helping fund MetaFilter
"The Sun Will Rise Without Thy Assistance" - Attributably?
June 18, 2013
There are a lot of places attributing the quote ""The sun will rise without thy assistance" to the Talmud. Is that true? If so, where does it say that in the Talmud? I would love to either verify or debunk this quote.
Writing & Language
(2 answers total)
3 users marked this as a favorite
I can find lots of references to it, going as far back as 1876
(the quote seems to be that the sun will SET, though). I can't find any specific reference to where in the Talmud it comes from.
on June 18, 2013
The wording close to what you posted is from a book by H. Polano from 1876 called "The Talmud: Selections."
Under proverbs and sayings of the Rabbis, he lists "The sun will set without thy assistance."
Now, I figured this is probably from Pirkei Avot(ethics of the Fathers), which is a collection of proverbs dealing with ethics, but its not.
The actual quote is in a couple of places in the Talmud, Pes 90b(6) // Naz 64b(16) which says "The sun sets of itself," so while your exact quote is not from the Talmud, a variation certainly is.
on June 19, 2013
What's a better way to refer t... | A co-worker/friend is selling ...
This thread is closed to new comments.
June 8, 2013
Words to Motivate!
January 19, 2011
What is the best, most flexible way to organize...
August 11, 2008
Holocaust memorabilia for sale?
May 19, 2007
Who says "it's important for educated people to...
January 31, 2007
Buy a Shirt
MetaFilter Network Inc.
All posts are © their original authors.