What do you do when the guy is In Complete Denial over his behavior with another woman?
Guy is completely and blatantly slobbering over another woman. It's totally obvious in both his body language and his conversations with her. But he won't admit it. A typical conversation is something like this:
You're drooling over her.
No, I'm not.
There's drool on your chin spilling onto the table.
No, there isn't.
He talks to her almost every day, asking her tons of questions about her life, what books she's read, whether she has any boyfriends.
You just asked her if she had any boyfriends, and when she said no, you lit up like a Christmas tree.
That's a perfectly normal question for one friend to ask another, and no, I didn't.
I even tried using taz's
great advice, where I tried to say "your behavior is wrong, you may not see it but you'll just have to trust me on this." It didn't work.
You guys were talking about weightlifting at the gym the other day, comparing arm muscles, and you grabbed her arm to feel it.
That was a gesture of friendship.
You invited her on a lunchtime walk, and complimented her new toenail polish.
That was a gesture of friendship.
[from taz, verbatim] You don't have to recognize or understand or even acknowledge the dynamic of what is happening here, but you have to trust that I do, and you have to do what is needed to protect us from threat/trouble from this area.
What area? What threat?
This has been going on for more than a year, and it's driving me crazy. Whenever I try to say "if you don't want to go out with her, then stop acting like you do," he'll just say, "I'm not acting like I do. How am I doing that?" And we'll get back into wrangling over specific details like the drool on the table.
I feel like he's gaslighting me, but if I were to say that, he'd just say, "but I'm not doing anything wrong." I can't tell whether he's just in denial about his feelings, or whether it just feels normal to him to drool over what is pretty, and therefore he genuinely doesn't see anything wrong with it. But I would like to talk about it.
I know that one answer is DTMFA, but I'd like to at least have an honest conversation first. But it's hard to have an honest conversation when he's got such a wall built up around the subject. So, what can I say to him that will break through the wall?
(We're all in our late 40s, nobody involved is married.)
- What is your relationship to this guy and this girl? Is this your boyfriend/girlfriend? Are they platonic friends of yours?
- Has the girl ever expressed discomfort with this attention, or is the problematic part coming from some other angle?
It makes a really big difference whether you're trying to defend her from actions she's uncomfortable with vs. actions you are uncomfortable with vs. trying to get your monogamous partner to knock it off with the attention to another woman.
posted by restless_nomad at 12:54 PM on September 8, 2012 [3 favorites]