Looking for an external hard drive
November 18, 2009 2:35 PM Subscribe
My external hard drive has been making some very odd noises for a while and I’m looking for a good replacement. Your input would be appreciated.
posted by The Lurkers Support Me in Email to computers & internet (12 answers total) 2 users marked this as a favorite
I’ve been using an external enclosure
for the last year or so, but shortly after I bought the drive it started taking a long
time to spin up (10+ seconds) before making a loud click sound and finally starting to read/write, during which time the app accessing the drive beachballs
. I think it would be a good idea to replace the enclosure with an actual external disk instead of the Super Nintendo-esque setup I've got now, but I'd like to run my criteria past the hive mind to get some advice first.
- I want something whisper-quiet. I live in a very small apartment and can't imagine how I used to put up with a noisy dual-GPU tower machine now that I have an iMac.
- The current drive is 1TB, but I'm considering going with a 2TB drive for a bit of extra space. Depends on the severity of the price jump.
- I want something reliable. My belief is that all consumer-grade hard disks are ticking timebombs that will all fail at some point, but I'd like to avoid buying another IBM Deathstar.
- Physical size is irrelevant; I'll be sticking it behind my display and never looking at it again. Performance is also a non-issue as it will only be used for Time Machine backups and bulk data storage.
- eSATA is unnecessary as my iMac doesn't have a connection, but it does have an unused FireWire port that I'd like to take advantage of (freeing up a USB port in the process).
I live in Canada and will probably be ordering from there, but I don't think there's much difference in cross-border product availability these days.