Students of meditation sometimes have trouble with pain when they sit in the same position for long periods. The advice many teachers give them is to make the pain the object of their meditation.Feeling ashamed, on its own, will not kill you. If you can learn to sit with it, rather than avoiding it or feeding it, perhaps you can learn how to let it flow away.
In depression we may be overcome with pain. It screams for our attention. We grow so tired of feeling pain that we will find nearly any way we can to avoid it. Sometimes we become so tangled up in our pain that all of our energy goes to fighting it.
Often we aren't even aware that this is what's happening. And when we respond in this way, we don't even really experience the pain, because we are running so fast to get away from it. Sometimes we become so accustomed to trying to ignore it that we may continue running even when the pain is gone.
Yet we can make pain the object of our attention, rather than a monster to flee from. We can begin by going beyond merely seeing it as "pain". We can examine the qualities of the pain, notice how it really feels. We can notice if the sensation in our body is one of heat, or tension, or pins and needles. We can notice whether we have tightened up around the pain, or if our whole body is on edge as we try to escape from it.
Then we can look more broadly at the ways we respond mentally. We may try to think of something else. Or we may tense up in the area around the pain -- though this serves only to block it, hold it in, and magnify it.
... Though it is at first frightening to examine our pain, once we have done so we can begin to soften to it, and really feel our suffering. We may worry that the feeling is too intense, that we won't be able to stand it. But ultimately we find that the pain we feel in trying to avoid what is happening is at least as bad as the uncomplicated pain underneath it, if not worse. And we may find, to our surprise, that the pain underneath becomes more bearable.
... When we can soften to our pain, and fear it less, we may find that we can begin to let the world back in again.
Exercise
Once you are sitting comfortably, focusing on your breath, bring your attention to any pain or discomfort you may feel. You may choose either physical or mental pain (the two usually don't exist apart from each other anyway).
As the pain begins to grow, remind yourself of your intention not to run from it but instead to explore it thoroughly. When you first become aware of it, identify it as simply "pain." Then move on to look closely at its qualities. Where in the body is it located? Does it remain constant, or does it increase and then decrease? Is it a sensation of cold or warmth; of tightness, or numbness, or pins and needles? Is it an ache or a burn?
What happens to your pain when you pay attention to it in this way? Does it lessen? Increase? Does it seem less like pain and more like discomfort?
Now look at the thoughts that arise along with the pain. Do you think the pain should not be happening? Are you feeling frightened or angry? Do you try to move a bit in order to lessen the pain? Does this help, or does the pain quickly return? Do you tighten in the area around the pain? Does your breathing become shallower or more rapid?
Try to relax into the pain. If you are tightening around it, or your breathing has changed, allow the muscles to relax and your breathing to slow. If possible, allow your thoughts to ease as well.
If you can remain with the pain, you may be able to see that, without your doing anything, it ebbs and flows, arising and disappearing like thoughts or other sensations. Does this surprise you when it happens? Have you ever noticed this with anything else?
I want to thank everyone for the responses thus far. I have always believed that this is a problem I was more-or-less alone in, and simply knowing that this afflicts other people has made me feel much better about the situation.posted by cortex at 7:23 AM on July 23, 2009
I should mention to all the people who suggested CBT that the kind of therapy I'm in, is, in fact, CBT, not unstructured talk therapy. But I need to address the problem with my therapist, for sure.
tigerbelly: That was a particularly helpful response, and I may take up your invitation to MeMail you at some later juncture - for now, I am still absorbing everything from this thread. I also double and triple check tickets and such, and and I also tend toward letting my mind plan fruitlessly instead of sleeping.
TwelveTwo: That sounds cathartic, and I will try it. When you wrote "For myself, I have a habit of trying to completely control other's interpretations of myself and I am pained whenever I fail at the impossibility", that resonated very strongly.
heatherann: I suspect I didn't give meditation a fair shot, and when I have time, I will take it up again. Certainly, I find passages like the ones you quoted poignant, true, and relevant.
painquale: "Before I had discovered that thread, I would sometimes mention to people that sometimes when I remembered a past embarrassing experience, I'd blurt something out or mumble something or pinch myself in order to distract myself, I guess." I actually do that too. Once again, I'm surprised that I'm not alone in that.
Again, thanks to everyone for the thoughtful and sensitive responses thus far, and if any other MeFites have anything to add, I will still be watching this thread, please contribute.
We have not talked about it at length, mostly because I find the idea of recounting these episodes that cause my feelings of shame to be ... shameful.
would it be easier to write them down?
posted by desjardins at 2:48 PM on July 22, 2009