Why do I only attract women who aren't into commitment? (Or who are poly, which I'm not. Or, sadly, who are just insane, and not insane in a "hi, I'm a misogynist who thinks that women who it doesn't work out with must be nuts" way, but insane in a "wait, you've actually spent time in a psych ward?!" way.)
I'm a single late-20's urban heterosexual male who is bad at wooing women, but I have enough attractive qualities (at least for certain niche markets, that I happen to like -- see details below) that fairly often I don't have to do so.
So the following pretty much summarizes my entire dating history:
1) Woman throws herself at me.
2) I find woman attractive (because, as noted, I like most of the niche market of women who prefer what I offer), get involved.
3) Blazing hot and fast romance.
4) Woman turns out not to be into commitment/looking for FWB, or polyamorous (which I can't do), or sometimes just downright insane. Unfortunately, I like serious, committed relationships. With sane women.
5) Disaster.
6) Repeat steps 1-6.
Often, it seems, these women see me as some kind of a conquest -- I seem to attract a lot of women who are insecure about and/or have a lot of their self-worth wrapped up into their ability to attract men. They seem to lose interest after they've successfully attracted/bedded me, and/or immediately start chasing other guys.
This has happened too often to be a coincidence. At this point, the flaw is obviously with me.
Help?! This has simply got to stop, stat! I want a normal relationship, damnit. Like everyone else I know.
The simple answer might be "try the women who don't throw themselves at you." Except, well, I seem to be a very niche commodity. That is, women will invariably either throw themselves at me or not be interested in me at all. I have a very poor success rate with women who don't actually throw themselves at me... does "wooing" ability, as a friend of mine recently suggested, actually make a difference in this sort of thing?
Details: I'm not particularly hunkey -- I'm pretty decent looking, but overweight. General consensus, plus experience from non-overweight periods, is that I'll be somewhat-to-significantly better-looking than average once I get into better shape. I'm sort of ostentatiously intelligent and tend to pick up something like high social status in most groups that I'm in. I'm pretty charming when my personality meshes with the woman, but can grate on (or simply have nothing to talk about with) those who don't. I don't dress particularly well or particularly badly. I'm a poor graduate student with moderately large future income potential, but I'm pretty sure money hasn't been a serious issue for any woman I've been involved with. I'm also the sort of guy who has almost all female friends, etc.
My niche market tends to be very smart (though often -- hell, always --, alas, insecure about it) and very attractive (but unconventionally so) nerdy, independent, feminist, usually-slightly-to-very-kinky, creative, funny women. All of which I like quite a lot, but for the whole inability to commit/frequent insanity thing. These women invariably have dozens of other guys hovering around, which doesn't help.
This post sounds totally egotistical, but, well, since it's an anon post, I don't really want to leave out detail. Sorry.
posted by anonymous to human relations (32 comments total)
9 users marked this as a favorite
You dont sound egotistical you sound slightly off, in the way that the girls you describe are.... (sorry if it sounds bad but it is kinda true, plus since is an anon post I didnt want to leave out any details). I just imagine you being in some sort of dinner date with a "normal" girl and you start sputtering these sort of sentences....
Anyway...you wanna meet nicer girls?
Go to different places (since I dont know where you go, I would say stop going there and stop meeting people in your social circle...unless they fit your requirements of course)
and
change your attitude and way of communicating....
P.S: (and I dont want to state the obvious but probably getting in shape will also help)
posted by The1andonly at 6:57 AM on November 18, 2008